Synthetic vs Natural Vitamins: What to Know About Multivitamins

Multivitamins are among the most popular food supplements. Most contain synthetically produced vitamins in a fixed combination. Whether this makes sense has been debated for years. In this article you will learn what synthetic vitamins are, where they differ from natural forms and how you can cover your needs through food.

What are synthetic vitamins?

Synthetic vitamins are produced chemically or with the help of microorganisms. Some are chemically identical to the form found in food, such as ascorbic acid as vitamin C. Others differ in their structure or do not occur in food in that form at all. What matters is therefore not only the origin but the specific form of a vitamin.

Examples: where the form makes a difference

Folic acid and folate: Folic acid is the synthetic form found in many supplements. The body first has to convert it into the active form. In foods such as liver and leafy greens, folate occurs in natural forms.

Vitamin B12: Many inexpensive supplements contain cyanocobalamin. In animal foods, B12 occurs mainly as methylcobalamin, adenosylcobalamin and hydroxocobalamin.

Vitamin E: Natural vitamin E (RRR-alpha-tocopherol, often labelled “d-alpha-tocopherol”) has a higher biological activity than synthetic “dl-alpha-tocopherol”, which is a mixture of different forms. Natural vitamin E is available, for example, as vitamin E from wheat germ oil.

Vitamin A: Supplements often contain retinyl acetate or beta-carotene. Liver supplies vitamin A directly as retinol together with other fat-soluble nutrients. Learn more in the article Beef liver: nutrients and vitamins.

Why dose and combination matter

Multivitamins combine many substances in one tablet. Some nutrients compete for absorption, for example zinc, copper and iron. Some products also contain individual vitamins in amounts far above daily requirements, while other nutrients are barely present. With fat-soluble vitamins such as A and D, high doses over a long period can lead to oversupply. Large studies have not shown a clear benefit of multivitamins in preventing chronic disease in healthy adults.

Ray Peat's view

Ray Peat was sceptical of isolated, high-dose supplements. He preferred nutrient-dense foods such as liver, milk, eggs and seafood and used individual substances only selectively. With multivitamins, he criticised among other things added iron and the high amounts of individual B vitamins. His statements on individual nutrients can be found in the collection Ray Peat quotes, for example Ray Peat on folic acid.

Covering vitamins through food

The most nutrient-dense foods are organ meats. Liver supplies vitamin A, B12, folate, copper and riboflavin. Heart is rich in B vitamins and coenzyme Q10. Oysters provide a lot of zinc. Add eggs, dairy products, meat, fish and fruit. If you do not like eating organ meats, you can choose dried organs, such as beef liver capsules or the organ complex. A food supplement does not replace a varied diet.

When supplements can make sense

There are situations in which targeted supplementation makes sense, such as vitamin D in winter, B12 on a fully plant-based diet or folate during pregnancy on medical advice. Ideally, have a deficiency confirmed by a doctor and then supplement in a targeted way rather than across the board.

Conclusion

Synthetic vitamins are not automatically bad, but the form, dose and combination make a difference. Many multivitamins contain inexpensive synthetic forms in a fixed mix that does not match individual needs. Covering vitamins through nutrient-dense foods and supplementing only where needed usually leads to better supply.

Back to the blog